If you're hosting Thanksgiving in Cary, IL this year, you don't have to dig through a big-box freezer for your turkey. Across McHenry, Lake and north Cook counties there are local butchers, a poultry shop and a family farm selling fresh birds, and most will special-order the size you need. Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, so here's who to call this week.
The Quick Version
Butcher on the Block, Lake in the Hills: Fresh Harrison's turkeys, 12 to 28 lbs.
Orchard Prime Meats & Wine Shoppe, Cary: Full-service butcher on Main Street.
Kalck's Butcher Shop, Crystal Lake: Family-run since 1975.
Wanda Farms, Harvard: Pasture-raised, $179 to $219.
Orchard Prime Meats, Lake Zurich: The original Orchard shop, with fresh holiday turkeys.
Tony's Butcher Shop, Grayslake: Neighborhood butcher on Route 83.
Prime Beef, Mundelein: Custom-cut butcher, open 7 days a week.
Heybeck's Meat Market, Barrington & Palatine: Schaul's all-natural turkeys, plus a ready-to-cook dinner.
Harrison's Poultry Farm, Glenview: The poultry shop that has been selling birds since 1893.
Hofherr Meat Co., Northfield: Ferndale turkeys at $6.59/lb.
McHenry County
1. Butcher on the Block (Lake in the Hills) 4660 W. Algonquin Rd. · 847-669-6679 This year's fresh turkeys come from Harrison's Poultry Farm in Glenview. Sizes go up in 4-lb steps from 12 lbs, but the 28-lb-plus size isn't available this year. They also carry fresh turkey breasts (4 to 10 lbs), plus smoked whole turkeys and smoked breasts while they last. The shop recommended ordering by Nov. 15, so call now to see what sizes are left. Thanksgiving week hours: Mon. 11/23 and Tue. 11/24, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.; Wed. 11/25, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.; closed Thanksgiving Day.
2. Orchard Prime Meats & Wine Shoppe (Cary) 133 W. Main St. · 847-639-3991 The only butcher shop right here in downtown Cary. Orchard opened in 1982 at Bell's Apple Orchard in Lake Zurich before adding the Cary shop, and its butchers will custom-order any meat and have it packed and ready on time.
3. Kalck's Butcher Shop (Crystal Lake) 71 E. Woodstock St. · 815-459-0016 Ken and Barbara Kalck opened this downtown Crystal Lake shop in 1975, and the family still runs it. The meat is cut daily and never frozen.
4. Wanda Farms (Harvard) 17419 Hebron Rd. · 815-323-4777 Pasture-raised turkeys from a McHenry County family farm. 2026 prices: small (10 to 12 lbs) $179, medium (14 to 16 lbs) $199, large (18 to 20 lbs) $219, each with a $75 deposit. Delivery weeks ran Nov. 3 to 17, so call today to ask if any birds are left.
Lake County
5. Orchard Prime Meats (Lake Zurich) 62 Old Rand Rd. · [confirm phone] Orchard's Lake Zurich shop has served the area for more than 30 years. It offers fresh turkeys for the holidays and takes phone orders.
6. Tony's Butcher Shop (Grayslake) 209 Barron Blvd. (Route 83) · 847-543-1960 A Grayslake butcher known for premium cuts and homemade specialties like bratwurst and meatloaf. Customers have ordered fresh Thanksgiving turkeys here.
7. Prime Beef (Mundelein) 416 Morris Ave. · 847-566-2333 A full-service butcher where the staff hand-trim and custom-cut to order, open seven days a week.
North Cook County
8. Heybeck's Meat Market & Gourmet Catering (Barrington & Palatine) Barrington: 227 N. Northwest Hwy. · 847-382-0835 · Palatine: 847-358-3820 Heybeck's sells fresh, all-natural, antibiotic- and hormone-free turkeys from Schaul's Gourmet, available seasoned or unseasoned. Ask about the ready-to-cook turkey dinner if you don't want to plan sides.
9. Harrison's Poultry Farm (Glenview) 1201 Waukegan Rd. · 847-724-0132 This is the family business behind Butcher on the Block's birds, serving the North Shore since 1893. Whole turkeys run from 12 to 28-plus lbs, with breasts from 4 to 10 lbs. Their butchers will prep your bird to your specifications at no extra charge. Harrison's often sells out, so call first.
10. Hofherr Meat Co. (Northfield) 300 Happ Rd. · [confirm phone] Hofherr sells whole Ferndale turkeys at $6.59/lb and split turkeys at $7.29/lb. If you'd rather skip the oven, it also offers a roasted-and-carved or smoked whole turkey for $175. Hours: Tue. to Fri., 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.; Sat., 10 to 5; Sun., 10 to 4; closed Mondays.
Let's Look at the Numbers
1.5 lbs per person: Butcher on the Block's rule of thumb (Harrison's says 1 lb per person, plus a half pound for leftovers). 10 guests means about a 15-lb bird.
$6.59/lb: Hofherr's Ferndale whole turkey. A 15-lb bird comes to about $99.
$179 to $219: Wanda Farms' pasture-raised turkeys, small to large.
3 counties, 10 spots: 4 in McHenry, 3 in Lake, 3 in north Cook.
1893: The year Harrison's started. It still supplies Butcher on the Block today.
10 days: From today (Nov. 16) to Thanksgiving. Most shops limit sizes, so order this week.
Local shops like these are part of what makes Cary and its neighbors feel like home. I track the local market the same way, street by street.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I buy a fresh Thanksgiving turkey near Cary, IL? In McHenry County: Orchard Prime Meats in Cary, Butcher on the Block in Lake in the Hills, Kalck's in Crystal Lake and Wanda Farms in Harvard. Lake County and north Cook County options are listed above.
Does Butcher on the Block in Lake in the Hills sell fresh turkeys? Yes. For 2026 its fresh turkeys come from Harrison's Poultry Farm in Glenview, from 12 to 28 lbs. Call 847-669-6679.
Where is Harrison's Poultry Farm? 1201 Waukegan Rd. in Glenview. It has been in business since 1893 and sells whole turkeys and turkey breasts. Call 847-724-0132.
How big a turkey do I need for Thanksgiving? Butcher on the Block recommends 1.5 lbs per person: 12 to 16 lbs for 8 to 10 people, or 20 to 24 lbs for 14 to 15.
Is there a farm in McHenry County that sells pasture-raised turkeys? Yes. Wanda Farms in Harvard sells pasture-raised turkeys from $179 to $219 with a $75 deposit. Call 815-323-4777 to check availability.
Is Butcher on the Block open on Thanksgiving Day? No. It is closed Thursday, Nov. 26, and closes at 4 p.m. on Wednesday, Nov. 25.
Happy Thanksgiving from Repta Residential
Thanks for shopping local. Our small businesses are a big part of why people love living in Cary and the towns around it.
Want to know what homes on your street are really selling for? Grab a time: https://calendar.app.google/qzSbBWWrNNtNNR5n9
Beth Repta, Repta Residential | #1 agent in Cary since 2017